TorquayFans.com | Torquay United Fans Forum

Tomorrow we will learn the full story but it means a 10 minute sin bin for a cynical foul or dissent.

It'll just mean more injuries. Coming off all muscles warmed up, sat on bench then coming back on. Surefire way for muscle strains and pulls. Stupid idea. They're bloody ruining our game

To be fair this is not a stupid idea at all, sin bins have been in operation at grassroots level for while, I've seen in action and it works very well, most players who've been sin binned do a short warm up 5 minutes into the period and all the games where I've seen a player sin binned not seen an injury occur yet.

How many times not just in post TUFC games but in other football has the talk been centred around a player being sent off ruining the game as a contest or spectacle, how many times have we talked or heard talk of a player being unlucky to be sent off as one of the two yellow cards wasn't warranted, having the option to use the sin bin will cut down on the number of red cards, and will enhance football.

As it will cut out cynical fouls and will improve player behaviour, as no manager will want players sat on the side-lines for 10 minutes, long overdue.

Seems to work ok in rugby.

Dave wrote: ↑08 Feb 2024, 19:00
How many times not just in post TUFC games but in other football has the talk been centred around a player being sent off ruining the game as a contest or spectacle, how many times have we talked or heard talk of a player being unlucky to be sent off as one of the two yellow cards wasn't warranted, having the option to use the sin bin will cut down on the number of red cards, and will enhance football.

Two blues or a blue and a yellow would mean a red and a sending off.

Great idea. Kids learn nothing from it being used at grass roots, it needs to come into the professional game where people can see it in effect and the impact of it. As a ref, I have used it and it is effective.

Just me not liking it then...

And me mate. Just another gimmick for the armchair fans. This simple game has enthralled millions for a century. Now they have to find 'entertainment' to keep the numbers subscribing. I propose that for the first 15 minutes defenders have to have their legs tied together, should she more goals. For the last 5 minutes the striker must wear a hood on his head and every other week one team will wear a large red nose and the opposition will wear large shoes instead of boots. The TV audience will increase as Man u struggle with controlling the ball and Liverpool attemp to overcome breathing difficulties caused by the large red nose. Eventually obstacles could be added to the playing area. Starting with hurdles on each goal area it could then progress to crocodiles and tigers patrolling the midfield. Millions will tune in to see if a big star gets his leg bitten of. We'll ger to see it 20000 times on VAR. As a great football manager once said, after a 1-nil scrappy win on a wet winter afternoon, if you wat to see entertainment go and watch clowns.

Surely a yellow then a blue card would mean a green not a red?

Wouldn't have thought 10 minutes in the sin bin will lead to injuries, after all they all have 15 minutes at half time!

I don't really like even more changes, but hopefully this'll cut down on the back chat, the trying to get players sent off etc.

How about introducing a mystery crate at the side of the pitch. On 40 minutes a player in neutral kit enters the field of play. Nobody knows which team he is going to play for. Oh the excitement as he suddenly charges at the opposition goal or exasperation as he scores for them. As the entertainment value then subsides a crocodile replaces the mystery player (Lion for international games). What a spectacle to see Marshall wrestling with the large crocodile as Lapslie attempts to break it's legs. The score at games will soon be forgotten as a new audience of not so football oriented pack grounds and TV subscriptions. International owners and Uncle Clark happy. Who knows he may start attending.

GULL 67 wrote: ↑09 Feb 2024, 19:30 How about introducing a mystery crate at the side of the pitch. On 40 minutes a player in neutral kit enters the field of play. Nobody knows which team he is going to play for. Oh the excitement as he suddenly charges at the opposition goal or exasperation as he scores for them. As the entertainment value then subsides a crocodile replaces the mystery player (Lion for international games). What a spectacle to see Marshall wrestling with the large crocodile as Lapslie attempts to break it's legs. The score at games will soon be forgotten as a new audience of not so football oriented pack grounds and TV subscriptions. International owners and Uncle Clark happy. Who knows he may start attending.

Football rules (and other sports) evolve over time as things change. There was a time before yellow and red cards, before panelty shootouts, before backpasses, before being able to take a kick off with one player.

If this can help to erradicate dissent and bring in a middle card for fouls which are more than a yellow but a red is too harsh, then all for it.

leetufc wrote: ↑09 Feb 2024, 20:23 Football rules (and other sports) evolve over time as things change. There was a time before yellow and red cards...

Indeed, I reminisce back to 1967 before the red card when Bristol City played Tottenham in the FA Cup and Spurs captain Dave Mackay refused to walk when the ref sent him off, After the match he said "I did not feel I deserved to go". The ref was left with no option but to just put Mackay's name in his book (like a yellow card booking) and let him play on. What a legend!

This is absolute horseshit