Angus Incident

Post a reply

Smilies
:goodpost: :lol: :rofl: :goal: :scarf: :keepie: :clap: :bow: :engflag: :-P :) :-D :nod: ;-) :-/ :( :'( :Z :@ :| :oops: :yellow: :red: :O :whistle: (*) (8) (D)

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: Angus Incident

Angus Incident

by Scott Brehaut » 30 Mar 2015, 14:50

That's just it though - the abuse has become untenable and beaten them down. It's natural that eventually somebody was going to snap.

Angus Incident

by arcadia » 30 Mar 2015, 14:27

Scott Brehaut wrote:So, just because a player isn't good enough, that gives "fans" permission to abuse them from the sides?

There's a difference between somebody shouting out "You're sh*t Rice" (and I use him as an example as he has been discussed above), and "Why don't you f*** off and die" etc.

Don't tell me it doesn't go on, because there are plenty of people that have heard it.
Scott I agree with you but these people should be evicted from the ground but the problem is we would have fewer spectators I've not heard the abuse as I watch from the other side of the ground perhaps I'm not in a position to comment but I do feel the players should not get involved as if you shout back it just encourages the abuse.

Angus Incident

by Scott Brehaut » 30 Mar 2015, 13:37

So, just because a player isn't good enough, that gives "fans" permission to abuse them from the sides?

There's a difference between somebody shouting out "You're shit Rice" (and I use him as an example as he has been discussed above), and "Why don't you **** off and die" etc.

Don't tell me it doesn't go on, because there are plenty of people that have heard it.

Angus Incident

by arcadia » 30 Mar 2015, 13:30

Scott Brehaut wrote: Try doing that for 40 odd games though, when you are getting constant abuse from "fans" such as the like that Dave highlighted above. The first few games you'd just ignore it - but after game 40 I'm sure you'd lose your head....I know I would.
Someone like the 'manager' should be telling the player he is not good enough if it continued as this is why the crowd is getting at him.
This is why some players ask for transfers!
I've never seen abuse carry on for a long time, if it did surely the club should organise the stewards to warn the abusers.

Angus Incident

by Scott Brehaut » 30 Mar 2015, 13:11

arcadia wrote:I do agree with a lot of what you are saying but that is what Torquay United are paying the stewards for to stop things like that happening. I have been always taught not to speak to anyone other than the team squad after the team talk and focas on the game.
Try doing that for 40 odd games though, when you are getting constant abuse from "fans" such as the like that Dave highlighted above. The first few games you'd just ignore it - but after game 40 I'm sure you'd lose your head....I know I would.

Angus Incident

by arcadia » 30 Mar 2015, 12:59

forevertufc wrote:But we're not talking about heckling, we're not talking about the groans from the crowd when a guilt edged chance to score was missed, or because a simple pass was misplaced, we're not talking about the odd shout from the crowd for a player to give more.

We're talking about full on personal abuse, often related to the player removing himself from the team and life, or things relating to a players family and worse.

Yes us fans get frustrated when things aren't going right, I do that's for sure. But I can not for the life me understand why people think, because they've paid there £20 they have the right shout what they like in the name of free speech and the fact they've paid their money so I'll do what I want.

If any of us went into our local hospital a shouted such abuse at the staff after being kept waiting, the police would be called and you'd be arrested, no shouts of I pay my National insurance is going justify those actions, same in a shop, you can't say I spend £100 a week in here, I can abuse the staff if I want to.

There has to be an understanding our players are under massive pressure right now, as is our captain, some of these lads will never have experienced pressure like it in their careers, then you have CH who says I'm the manager it's my job to take the pressure of these lads. Well it's game 40 feel free to step in any time you like Mr Hargreaves, oh, of course fans blaming the players kind of suits you down to the ground, doesn't it.
I do agree with a lot of what you are saying but that is what Torquay United are paying the stewards for to stop things like that happening. I have been always taught not to speak to anyone other than the team squad after the team talk and focas on the game.

Angus Incident

by Dave » 30 Mar 2015, 10:03

But we're not talking about heckling, we're not talking about the groans from the crowd when a guilt edged chance to score was missed, or because a simple pass was misplaced, we're not talking about the odd shout from the crowd for a player to give more.

We're talking about full on personal abuse, often related to the player removing himself from the team and life, or things relating to a players family and worse.

Yes us fans get frustrated when things aren't going right, I do that's for sure. But I can not for the life me understand why people think, because they've paid there £20 they have the right shout what they like in the name of free speech and the fact they've paid their money so I'll do what I want.

If any of us went into our local hospital a shouted such abuse at the staff after being kept waiting, the police would be called and you'd be arrested, no shouts of I pay my National insurance is going justify those actions, same in a shop, you can't say I spend £100 a week in here, I can abuse the staff if I want to.

There has to be an understanding our players are under massive pressure right now, as is our captain, some of these lads will never have experienced pressure like it in their careers, then you have CH who says I'm the manager it's my job to take the pressure of these lads. Well it's game 40 feel free to step in any time you like Mr Hargreaves, oh, of course fans blaming the players kind of suits you down to the ground, doesn't it.

Angus Incident

by arcadia » 29 Mar 2015, 17:23

:goodpost:
Trojan 67 wrote:Comedians do it like watter of a ducky's back - give hecklers as good as they get. Offering them outside during a show is absolutely unprofessional conduct. This is the difference between a professional comedian and an amateur comedian playing at trying to be a professional footballer.

:engflag:

Angus Incident

by Trojan 67 » 29 Mar 2015, 17:16

Comedians do it like watter of a ducky's back - give hecklers as good as they get. Offering them outside during a show is absolutely unprofessional conduct. This is the difference between a professional comedian and an amateur comedian playing at trying to be a professional footballer.

:engflag:

Angus Incident

by arcadia » 29 Mar 2015, 16:36

forevertufc wrote:Well having heard some of the personal dogs abuse shouted out some of our players during the course of this season, I'm hardly surprised it's getting the point some of them our offering fans outside, the abuse is equally embarrassing as some of our teams performances, personal abuse directed at the players is not called regardless of any circumstance.

There is no way our current league position can be blamed on Martin Rice, he does have clear limitations, he may not have the overall ability for this level, that's probably not doubted by anyone, but also to be fair Ricey isn't helped by the most calamitous 'keystones kops' back four that play in front of him.

Some say Ricey doesn't know whether to stick our twist, with this back four, I'm pretty sure Joe Hart wouldn't know either.

I'm sure there are some who will back me up here, when it comes to goalkeeping 9-10ths of the law is CONFIDENCE, how does it help Ricey's confidence when he keeps conceding goals that he has no chance of keeping out, from situations that should have been, and would been defended properly by school boys.

I will be the first to agree, the goalkeeping position is one that needs looking at along with the entire back four, Angus MacDonald, maybe at a push Aaron Downes all tough don't see that happening are the only ones I'd keep, the rest including Ives are not good enough period.
Golden rule a professional footballer does not get involved with the crowd.
You said Rice has his limitations but and does not deserve the abuse I agree but it happens. Joe Hart would have kept us in the top half of the league as he would have organised the bad back four. Ives in a better set up would be good enough, the problem is the players he's playing with have lost confidence and a few need their backsides kicked. It's a great shame Angus is out injured as you said he is a leader. Downes legs have gone he's lost when one on one when the ball gets behind him.
Rice made the same mistakes through the years and when he's came into the side at the end of last season he played above expectation and Hargreaves gave him the benefit of doubt which was a big mistake as there are better non-league keepers about. :keepie:

Angus Incident

by Southampton Gull » 29 Mar 2015, 11:03

Akin to a fan arguing with stewards while a match is in progress maybe?

You couldn't imagine such a thing could you?

Angus Incident

by brucie » 29 Mar 2015, 10:18

No I don't actually think that Rice deserves any abuse from a couple of drunks. I agree that is out of order. But its a football match so probably nothing he hasn't heard before.
What I object to is that Rice appeared to engage the two supporters - no doubt if they got a reaction then that would make them carry on.
Surely its all about focusing on the match in progress. If you are arguing with supporters then you are clearly not focusing on the match.
Its much the same as the MAcdonald incident. Being pulled away from your supporters by your captain when the ball is in play is possible one of the most ridiculous things I have ever seen.
Its just making us look more amateur than ever.

Angus Incident

by MidDevon » 29 Mar 2015, 09:48

When Chris came to the club as manager, he made a big point of saying he was attracting players as much on their character and how they fit in as their talent. I cannot remember exactly what he said but it was down those lines

Looking back I thought this was inexperienced manager talk. In business and in football , it is not a popularity contest, and especially in football it is raw talent that counts.

Over the years we have had some real "spanners" play for us, the likes of Chris Zebroski and Matt Green come to find in recent years, difficult to manage agreed, but you avoid players like that at your peril.

I have said on this forum before that I think CH's biggest problem is that he is the lover of some players, get's on well with most others and therefore manages very few.

I am only watching from the side-lines, like most of us, but "ego driven!" assertive, arrogant players can sometimes help to drive the dressing room

Angus Incident

by Neal » 29 Mar 2015, 09:29

forevertufc wrote:Well having heard some of the personal dogs abuse shouted out some of our players during the course of this season, I'm hardly surprised it's getting the point some of them our offering fans outside, the abuse is equally embarrassing as some of our teams performances, personal abuse directed at the players is not called regardless of any circumstance.

There is no way our current league position can be blamed on Martin Rice, he does have clear limitations, he may not have the overall ability for this level, that's probably not doubted by anyone, but also to be fair Ricey isn't helped by the most calamitous 'keystones kops' back four that play in front of him.

Some say Ricey doesn't know whether to stick our twist, with this back four, I'm pretty sure Joe Hart wouldn't know either.

I'm sure there are some who will back me up here, when it comes to goalkeeping 9-10ths of the law is CONFIDENCE, how does it help Ricey's confidence when he keeps conceding goals that he has no chance of keeping out, from situations that should have been, and would been defended properly by school boys.

I will be the first to agree, the goalkeeping position is one that needs looking at along with the entire back four, Angus MacDonald, maybe at a push Aaron Downes all tough don't see that happening are the only ones I'd keep, the rest including Ives are not good enough period.
:goodpost:

Totally agree with this. Ricey is not the best GK we have had, but do think HE DOES HIS BEST, and it isn't hes fault either. The back four are poor. Only Downes and Angus are good enough for this level (and only just I might add). They are even worse as a unit I would add.

Rice has been a good servant, played second fiddle for a whole season, doesn't earn the highest wage at the club, totally unfair to single him out like some do. But these people like and enjoy pointing the finger and scapegoating, its a mild type of bullying and I don't like it!

The only time I will shout at one of our players is if I think they are taking the piss, that is "NOT TRYING"! And Rice does try!

Angus Incident

by SWgull » 29 Mar 2015, 08:46

Martin Rice does not deserve the abuse, agreed. Or any other player. The truth is that, despite what people think, berating players does nothing to help and just poisons the atmosphere at the club still further.

Top