by MellowYellow » 09 Apr 2019, 16:53
Yorkieandy wrote: 09 Apr 2019, 13:39
I think we all understand why fans sometimes run onto the pitch in celebration as it's an instinctive, split second decision borne out of joy but 'by the letter of the law' they all must face sanctions for this, whatever the law states that should be. Regardless of whether you think it's OTT or not common sense is totally irrelevant
Whilst I recognise the point you make - I nonetheless beg to differ on your rigid application of the law.
Some of the laws that govern football are ridiculous. The rules on pitch encroachment are too broad. As I have previously said we want to prevent pitch invasions, not criminalise and throttle someone who steps over a line by a few centimetres while celebrating.
Take for instance the
Football (Offences) Act 1991
'
Throwing of missiles onto the playing area or into the crowd - s.2'
We all know that throwing coins can blind someone or cause other serious injury. If the individuals who throw coins or flares for that matter, can be identified, I am sure we would all welcome the full force of the law being used. However, technically, within the “missile throwing” provisions, throwing the match ball back on to the pitch can be a criminal offence. Would you really want someone to feel the full force of the law in that scenario?
Let take another example, you throw the match balll to a 12 year old kid in the stadium, who who desperately wants to be the one who throws the ball back on to the pitch, which the boy duly does. Yes, I am afraid that technically can be a criminal offence too... for both you and the boy. Does that really warrant a conditional cautions where you and the boy cannot attend a football match for a minimum of 3 years, but must attend a police station at kick off times for that duration.
Then there's the
'Sporting Events (Control of Alcohol etc.) Act 1985'
You carry a pack of 4 cans of beer in the boot of the car on the way to the match (not drinking it) ..... criminal offence
You drink one of your cans of beer in sight of the pitch -.. criminal offence
The rules are outdated and ridiculous. When the law is contrary to common sense, the proverbial expression "
The Law is an Ass" springs to mind.
[quote=Yorkieandy post_id=239167 time=1554817176 user_id=23508]
I think we all understand why fans sometimes run onto the pitch in celebration as it's an instinctive, split second decision borne out of joy but 'by the letter of the law' they all must face sanctions for this, whatever the law states that should be. Regardless of whether you think it's OTT or not common sense is totally irrelevant
[/quote]
Whilst I recognise the point you make - I nonetheless beg to differ on your rigid application of the law.
Some of the laws that govern football are ridiculous. The rules on pitch encroachment are too broad. As I have previously said we want to prevent pitch invasions, not criminalise and throttle someone who steps over a line by a few centimetres while celebrating.
Take for instance the [b]Football (Offences) Act 1991[/b]
'[b]Throwing of missiles onto the playing area or into the crowd - s.2'[/b]
We all know that throwing coins can blind someone or cause other serious injury. If the individuals who throw coins or flares for that matter, can be identified, I am sure we would all welcome the full force of the law being used. However, technically, within the “missile throwing” provisions, throwing the match ball back on to the pitch can be a criminal offence. Would you really want someone to feel the full force of the law in that scenario?
Let take another example, you throw the match balll to a 12 year old kid in the stadium, who who desperately wants to be the one who throws the ball back on to the pitch, which the boy duly does. Yes, I am afraid that technically can be a criminal offence too... for both you and the boy. Does that really warrant a conditional cautions where you and the boy cannot attend a football match for a minimum of 3 years, but must attend a police station at kick off times for that duration.
Then there's the [b] 'Sporting Events (Control of Alcohol etc.) Act 1985'[/b]
You carry a pack of 4 cans of beer in the boot of the car on the way to the match (not drinking it) ..... criminal offence
You drink one of your cans of beer in sight of the pitch -.. criminal offence
The rules are outdated and ridiculous. When the law is contrary to common sense, the proverbial expression "[b]The Law is an Ass"[/b] springs to mind.