Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

Post a reply

Smilies
:goodpost: :lol: :rofl: :goal: :scarf: :keepie: :clap: :bow: :engflag: :-P :) :-D :nod: ;-) :-/ :( :'( :Z :@ :| :oops: :yellow: :red: :O :whistle: (*) (8) (D)

BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[flash] is OFF
[url] is ON
Smilies are ON

Topic review
   

Expand view Topic review: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by tufcbrett » 22 Jul 2011, 11:50

We dont need to worry about Bobby. Using his weaker foot and still getting it to the half way line, better than most out field players it must be said.
As Ling said playing 100 games in the SPL? If thats true then we have a perfectly good enough keeper and must put him up there as one of the top keepers in the league.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by SteveDeckchair » 22 Jul 2011, 11:44

Bigman wrote:Only going on the friendly reports on this site, my one concern on Bobby would be kicking, which a few people have said hasn't been great. I'm very happy for him to throw or roll it out to defenders for them to distribute, or throw long if he can do that, but there'll be times when he gets a backpass and has to punt long first time. I saw several keepers last season whose kicks didn't get sufficient distance or height to clear the advancing forward line, thus putting their team immediately under pressure. To his credit, although I never liked his up and unders from his hands Bevs tended to get good height on his clearances to give us a moment to recover when needed. If Bobby can't get these clearances away then his shot stopping ability may be tested more than we'd like, but hopefully this won't actually be a problem.

With regards to topic, I have no idea ^.^
Don't worry bigman. Bobby is extremely capable with the ball at his feet. His kicking is just fine. Haven't seen the same distance as Bevan yet, but if he's carrying a knock, you won't get that.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by JamieE » 22 Jul 2011, 09:32

Regarding his kicking, Ling said on his post Exeter GullsPlayer interview that Bobby is kicking with his weaker foot recently as he has a slight groin problem.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by Bigman » 22 Jul 2011, 09:29

Only going on the friendly reports on this site, my one concern on Bobby would be kicking, which a few people have said hasn't been great. I'm very happy for him to throw or roll it out to defenders for them to distribute, or throw long if he can do that, but there'll be times when he gets a backpass and has to punt long first time. I saw several keepers last season whose kicks didn't get sufficient distance or height to clear the advancing forward line, thus putting their team immediately under pressure. To his credit, although I never liked his up and unders from his hands Bevs tended to get good height on his clearances to give us a moment to recover when needed. If Bobby can't get these clearances away then his shot stopping ability may be tested more than we'd like, but hopefully this won't actually be a problem.

With regards to topic, I have no idea ^.^

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by HRG » 22 Jul 2011, 06:56

Well after all this glowing praise I'd better make sure I get to the Truro game to see the man in action.
Getting very excited about the new season now after hearing such good reports of our newbies and the team in general.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by SteveDeckchair » 21 Jul 2011, 22:27

Very pleased with Bobby so far. Unbelievable throwing it straight to the centre forward's head on the half way line! :nod:

I also couldn't believe it, seeing him take goal kicks with both feet. He played one with his right peg out to the right wing!!

Bevan was a good keeper at this level though in spite of his short comings. He more often than not did the business for us and certainly wasn't what you would call a dodgy keeper even though his ball control with his feet is poor.

BritishGAS, perhaps you haven't seen him kicking the ball first time on a back pass yet. You will! Also, notice his strange kicking style (probably the reason he struggles with the kicking) and the fact that he has to come out early at half time to warm up on the pitch. It's the long leg muscles you know!

Bobby looks to be a different class though. Well done Martin Ling. :clap:

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by bc-gull » 21 Jul 2011, 21:51

BritishGAS wrote: I have to pick you up on that first bit.

I guess you are only stating your opinion on what you have saw of Bevan.

But I must say, Bevan has been great at throwing the ball out quickly to our full backs in the friendlies he has played in. It has been a joy to watch and Lee Brown, Micheal Smith and Micheal Boateng have been 3 of our best performers in the friendlies, largely down to Bevan releasing the ball quickly to them and setting up quick counter attacks.
hmm, I have to say though, whenever there was a pass back to him I think everyone nearly sh*t themselves, his kicking is atrocious and with his height he should be claiming more balls in the air. Buckle seems to rate him though so good luck..

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by BritishGAS » 21 Jul 2011, 21:44

TUFCforever wrote:Bevan is a good shot stopper when he sees them. His kicking is woeful, he never throws it out to his left and right backs and never comes off his line and does not command the area like he should. But Bobby on the other hand has experience of big games lets not forget he has played at Parkhead and Ibrox in sell out games so he is used to pressure. He talks constantly to the back four and the only other keeper recently that I can remember doing that for us was the legend that is Neville Southall. He never kicked one single ball last out of his hands he always looked to give to a avaliable player and build from the back or throw it to just over the half way line. He commands his area well and I have full confidence in him and Martin Ling has done his homework and improved that position for us from last season. :engflag:
I have to pick you up on that first bit.

I guess you are only stating your opinion on what you have saw of Bevan.

But I must say, Bevan has been great at throwing the ball out quickly to our full backs in the friendlies he has played in. It has been a joy to watch and Lee Brown, Micheal Smith and Micheal Boateng have been 3 of our best performers in the friendlies, largely down to Bevan releasing the ball quickly to them and setting up quick counter attacks.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by Louis » 21 Jul 2011, 21:31

TGAGU - you can change it from the user control panel ;-)

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by TheGullsAreGoingUp » 21 Jul 2011, 21:29

ferrarilover wrote: Look at your username. Now look at the bit I have highlighted. Do you see the problem I have with this?

Matt.
I do see this, the username was the first thing that came into my mind, no thought at all, I wish you could change it, but no point now. :-/

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by TUFCforever » 21 Jul 2011, 21:20

Bevan is a good shot stopper when he sees them. His kicking is woeful, he never throws it out to his left and right backs and never comes off his line and does not command the area like he should. But Bobby on the other hand has experience of big games lets not forget he has played at Parkhead and Ibrox in sell out games so he is used to pressure. He talks constantly to the back four and the only other keeper recently that I can remember doing that for us was the legend that is Neville Southall. He never kicked one single ball last out of his hands he always looked to give to a avaliable player and build from the back or throw it to just over the half way line. He commands his area well and I have full confidence in him and Martin Ling has done his homework and improved that position for us from last season. :engflag:

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by ferrarilover » 21 Jul 2011, 21:13

TheGullsAreGoingUp wrote:To be quite honest, I feel that with a little more league 2 experience under his belt, he could well be in a few seasons the best goalkeeper in league 2 for sure, however I feel we still cannot judge him, although he seems good on paper, and although in the 3 friendlies he has participated in he has done well (even if he didn't have to do much). I do however feel very comfortable with ole' Bobby, and I feel that he was a great signing in a vital position.
Look at your username. Now look at the bit I have highlighted. Do you see the problem I have with this?

Matt.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by Fonda » 21 Jul 2011, 21:10

Bevan has excellent reflexes for a big man. He has great ability to get down quickly and make awkward saves look simple. But he never leaves his line. If a cross comes into the 6-yard box he'll take it, as you'd expect a man of his height to do. But anything further out than that he doesn't want to know about, and it puts pressure on defenders. His distribution is woeful too, and he can't be relied upon to stay fit.

Olejnik hasn't really been tested yet, but what i already like about him is that every shot sticks. Nothing bounces off of him, as he takes everything so cleanly. He's not yet looked anything other than comfortable when crosses come into the box, and his distribution, is fantastic. Comfortably clearing the half-way line with throws is Schmeicel-esque, and a great weapon for starting counter attacks. I'm comfortable already he's a more solid keeper.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by TheGullsAreGoingUp » 21 Jul 2011, 21:03

To be quite honest, I feel that with a little more league 2 experience under his belt, he could well be in a few seasons the best goalkeeper in league 2 for sure, however I feel we still cannot judge him, although he seems good on paper, and although in the 3 friendlies he has participated in he has done well (even if he didn't have to do much). I do however feel very comfortable with ole' Bobby, and I feel that he was a great signing in a vital position.

Re: Best Goalkeeper in league 2?

by ferrarilover » 21 Jul 2011, 20:13

With Bevan and Pickles replaced with Bobby and Saah, we are certainly have much better distribution and ball retention prospects

Matt.

Top