Torquay United Fans Forum

You asked me a question, and I answered it for you. Namely - "How can you seriously have a Man of the Match award for one of the most abject results in the club's history?"

There will be 46 of these threads a season regardless of whether we win, draw or lose to a team without a goalkeeper. We have already had a few names put forward, so there will be a man of the match for the Sutton game, and they'll be added to all the other individual games.

The purpose of the MOTM threads are to collate the votes. If you want to discuss any other topics in them, then go ahead, but I don't see why you would want to when the whole rest of the forum exists for exactly this purpose.

[quote=Gulliball post_id=200736 time=1488143639 user_id=101]
[i][b]If you're not happy with how the club is playing/managed/owned/run, then you have the use of pretty much every other thread to express your opinions, without interrupting this feature.[/b][/i] [quote]

Does your position Administrator entitle you to control the posts others make then?

I was expressing an opinion, Suggesting that no-one be out up for MotM for this game; not suggesting the whole thing should be scrapped.

I've cast my vote by 'not voting'!

[quote="merse btpir" post_id=200732 time=1488139849 user_id=23969]
How can you seriously have a Man of the Match award for one of the most abject results in the club's history?

It defies logic really; almost as much as giving that shower of shit a round of applause when they come over looking for sympathy
[/quote]

This feature is now in it's seventh season, and has used the same format since day one (as per the intro below).

Yesterday was an opportunity for 3 points in the same way as any other game, so will count for 1/46th of the total - the same weight as every other game. The idea is to find a fan voted player of the season, not a fan voted player of the bits of the season we play well in.

We've have some horrible games in the last 7 years, but there's always been this thread created after the game and it's not going to change format midway through the season.

If you're not happy with how the club is playing/managed/owned/run, then you have the use of pretty much every other thread to express your opinions, without interrupting this feature.

[quote]
Man of the Match is a feature that has been running on TorquayFans.com since the beginning of the 2010/11 season. After each league game, a thread is created for fans who attended the match to vote for their top five performers in order. After each game the results are added up with the winning player declared the Man of the Match. However all nominated players receive points, weighted in order of how highly the fans rated them.

The idea is that each game counts for 1/46th of the final total, therefore every game counts equally. The Tuesday night away at Accrington when we lose 5-0 was a potential three points in the same way that a home victory over Plymouth is worth three points, but one will always be remembered better than the other when reflecting back on the season. Likewise, performances towards the end of the season are more highly valued in the traditional player of the year voting. With this format, every game is scored on an individual basis, and is then added together to give the final total, which over the full season should remove as much bias as possible and hopefully give an accurate measure.
[/quote]

The results are collated over a season. It doesn't matter if it's the best or worst performance, if players are worthy of a mention then great. If not then so be it. The stats are a welcome read at the end of a season (usually).

How can you seriously have a Man of the Match award for one of the most abject results in the club's history?

It defies logic really; almost as much as giving that shower of shit a round of applause when they come over looking for sympathy

Reid
Young
Williams

I can't give any credit to other players after that

Keating put more effort in the few minutes he was on than any of the side
Young back where he should be playing.

Reid put effort in but???????????

Hodgkiss. Solid performance. Consistent.
Young. Very committed performance.
Reid. Did well in trying conditions but missed great chance at 1-0 when shooting over the bar on 20 minutes.
Williams. Alert took his goal well.
Keating. I think Nicho should start him and say give it everything you have for 45 minutes. He could surprise us.

Reid always puts in a shift when he plays but unfortunately isn't going to score us any goals.
Excluding Moore who has to look at himself for goals 2 and 3 if at least 7 of the outfield players who were a disgrace yesterday put in half the effort each game that Reid does we would be getting more points.
I exclude Young, Hodgkiss, Williams, Sparkes & Keating plus Reid.

Williams
Young
Reid

For at least trying. No one else though

Can we start a new thread for the worst player of the match - there would be plenty of competition for that! 'Lets just hoof the ball aimlessly in the air' McGinty would be fighting off 'I can't defend to save my life' Anderson, 'I am no footballer' LRT and 'I am coming for the ball but perhaps not' Moore for the (dis)honour!

No offence but pointless thread.

Nobody should claim any credit from that performance.

If pushed, I'd give it to the fans for staying for the full 90 minutes.

[quote=Louis post_id=200674 time=1488062092 user_id=2]


Agree with this so x2 the above please
[/quote]

Make that 3.

[quote=forevertufc post_id=200660 time=1488054357 user_id=65]
Purely on effort alone.

Reid
Young
Williams
[/quote]

Agree with this so x2 the above please

Jared Hodgkiss
Luke Young

Purely on effort alone.

Reid
Young
Williams