Page 3 of 14

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 13:13
by PhilGull
Yellow4life wrote:http://postimg.org/image/4gnpxva3v/

Why would he be in the legends team, if he was staying?
Because he is a club legend. Still being employed by the club doesn't alter that.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 13:23
by Rjc70
PhilGull wrote: Because he is a club legend. Still being employed by the club doesn't alter that.
He'll have accepted it as a wave to the fans trying his arm for a few more quid opportunity. I'm glad he's started to behave himself on twitter after the other night. I wish him well, but hope he gets the move he craves. I wouldn't begrudge him his Argyle move. Some would, I suppose.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 18:15
by chunkygull
PhilGull wrote:Regardless of what you think of Mansell today if what he has done in the 7 years previous doesn't qualify him as a club legend then what does? He was an integral part of four play-off teams, captaining two and a cup final team and most importantly of all spent the middle 5 of those 7 years as a fans favourite, in everyone's top three favourite players!
If he isn't a legend then who is? Oh sorry, I forgot about all those players back in the 60s and 70s who lifted all those trophies in our glory days! ;-)

As for reasons for keeping him, well we need experience. If we start next season with a squad full of players all under 25 then we will not get promoted. The best teams in the Conference have a wealth of experience with a smattering of youth. We need players like Mansell if we are going to bounce back.
I would love to know what player you have been watching and who these mystery fans are. Most fans I have ever discussed Mansell with are either indifferent about him, think he is over-rated, dont rate him at all or cant understand how he has been here so long. :| Other than his best season, the play-off year under Ling, he has been bang average to poor, although his work rate and commitment has been great and much better than most.

He is not a legend, not many players are deserving of that accolade.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 18:25
by DevonYellow
PhilGull wrote:Regardless of what you think of Mansell today if what he has done in the 7 years previous doesn't qualify him as a club legend then what does? He was an integral part of four play-off teams, captaining two and a cup final team and most importantly of all spent the middle 5 of those 7 years as a fans favourite, in everyone's top three favourite players!
If he isn't a legend then who is? Oh sorry, I forgot about all those players back in the 60s and 70s who lifted all those trophies in our glory days! ;-)

As for reasons for keeping him, well we need experience. If we start next season with a squad full of players all under 25 then we will not get promoted. The best teams in the Conference have a wealth of experience with a smattering of youth. We need players like Mansell if we are going to bounce back.
You forgot to include two relegations.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 18:30
by Southampton Gull
Three if you add Oxford ;-)

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 18:34
by Kernowgull
Also playing in the legends game is Tom Stocco. If Stocco is a legend, I'll give Mansell that status too ;-)

Mansell gone?

Posted: 15 May 2014, 22:01
by Rjc70
PhilGull wrote: Because he is a club legend. Still being employed by the club doesn't alter that.
Not in the Legends squad on .com. Jo Kuffour is. And Hilly - a true legend.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 16 May 2014, 01:28
by ferrarilover
JK4, would we have him back? Has been released by Wycombe.

Matt.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 16 May 2014, 07:27
by gullno4
absolutely, far better than anything we've got!

Mansell gone?

Posted: 16 May 2014, 08:32
by Rjc70
Agree.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 16 May 2014, 12:22
by yellowforever
He is definitely better than what we've got, but I imagine he'd want a decent wage and I'd prefer Midson over him.

In all honesty, I'd prefer it if we didn't sign any ex-players - its time to move on.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 16 May 2014, 16:50
by cambgull
I wouldn't mind a Midson and Kuffour partnership, that would be a great combination.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 28 May 2014, 23:07
by DerbyshireGull
So has Mansell gone or not? If not why not?

I will concede he can do a perfectly adequate job for us in the conference but his presence has now become untenable IMO and regardless should be dispensed with respectfully at all costs. We need a new dawn at Plainmoor. His time is up.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 29 May 2014, 08:10
by Richinns
DerbyshireGull wrote:So has Mansell gone or not? If not why not?

I will concede he can do a perfectly adequate job for us in the conference but his presence has now become untenable IMO and regardless should be dispensed with respectfully at all costs. We need a new dawn at Plainmoor. His time is up.
Way too harsh.

Mansell gone?

Posted: 29 May 2014, 08:30
by Plymouth Gull
I can only assume Andy is still devastated that his beloved Derby lost in the POF, Rich.

Even though Manse has gone stale in the last two years, no fan can deny that his spell down here has been a decent one - he (like Nicho) deserves a warm send off if he does move on.