Page 1 of 26
Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:29
by Richinns
I would firstly give Benyon a contract (no brianer!).
I would also keep - Cruise, Yeoman, Jarvis, Saah, Downes, Leadbitter, Rice (has done nothing wrong and has earned the back-up role) and Rene (although I think this is very unlikely and already has something lined up)
I would say good bye to Stevens, Macklin (has been nowhere recently), Oastler, Morris, Halpin, Easton
Mods - can you do a sticky like last year as to where the squad stands and rumours etc? (this was most useful through the summer period).
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:38
by wivelgull
I think we need a more ruthless clear-out, otherwise there'll be a repeat of this season's disaster next time round. We want promotion! That's the bottom line, and most (not all - no names) of the present squad won 't achieve that aim.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:43
by usagullmichigan
wivelgull wrote:I think we need a more ruthless clear-out, otherwise there'll be a repeat of this season's disaster next time round. We want promotion! That's the bottom line, and most (not all - no names) of the present squad won 't achieve that aim.

This is Torquay
Mid table finish it is then
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:45
by AustrianAndyGull
Pretty much the same as yours Richinns except i might be tempted to keep Morris and i don't want to see Rene in a Torquay shirt again.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:48
by Fonda
I think Manse, Nico, Poke, Bodin, and Craig have deals?
Supplementary to this, I’d offer deals to Saah, Downes, Cruise, Lathrope, Morris and Howe.
Shift the rest on and start recruitment early (make Benners a priority). Lets not wait until late July, when everyone else has had their pick.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:50
by Plymouth Gull
Rich. I will work on a thread like I did last year pretty sharpish!
Anticipating a busy summer ahead so I'll get it started early.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:52
by Richinns
NickGull wrote:Rich. I will work on a thread like I did last year pretty sharpish!
Anticipating a busy summer ahead so I'll get it started early.
Thanks Nick - top man!
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:55
by Fonda
Joe Anyinsah released by Rovers. That'd be a start.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:56
by Plymouth Gull
No worries Rich

Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 10:59
by Richinns
Fonda wrote:Joe Anyinsah released by Rovers. That'd be a start.
Agree - would be an excellent addition IMO
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 11:00
by cambgull
I'd like to see Anyinsah here, seems to be quick with a bit of a poachers instinct at times too. Only worry is that he might still be asking for a fair wedge of dollar.
For me, I'd keep the ones under contract as well as Saah, Downes, Cruise and Howe. That would be about it. As for the maybe pile, I wouldn't be annoyed by any means to see Morris there too. I'd like to go back to a smaller squad with better quality players again, using the loan market to boost if we need to.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 11:02
by Kernowgull
Jarvis has to be offered a contract, and I'd offer Morris as well providing he's fully recovered. Get in Benyon and Yeoman, ditch Steven and Macklin and spend their wages on one more striker. Jarvo, Yeoman, Benners plus one other would give us great attacking options
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 11:06
by Fonda
You have more confidence in Jarvis than me. He's scored 3 or 4 important goals, but I don't think he's anywhere near prolific enough to warrant a place in a squad as small as ours. Yeoman perhaps does deserve another year.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 11:10
by cambgull
Ahh yes, I'd keep Jarvis too.
I'm still not fussed by Yeoman. But then I like my players to be experts at one particular thing. Yeoman is not tall and can win headers, he's not small and nippy, he's middling height, not particularly quick and doesn't have a poachers instinct like Benyon does. Unless he's on cheap wages, I don't think he's worth keeping when we have two players who are not totally dissimilar and better players.
Re: Retain or Release?
Posted: 29 Apr 2013, 11:13
by Richinns
cambgull wrote:Ahh yes, I'd keep Jarvis too.
I'm still not fussed by Yeoman. But then I like my players to be experts at one particular thing. Yeoman is not tall and can win headers, he's not small and nippy, he's middling height, not particularly quick and doesn't have a poachers instinct like Benyon does. Unless he's on cheap wages, I don't think he's worth keeping when we have two players who are not totally dissimilar and better players.
Supposedly he is the most natural goalscorer at the club. For this reason I would give him another year as a possible option from the bench.